The logic of mass firings is brutal: Make it impossible for undocumented workers to earn a living, buy food, pay rent, or send money home to their children.

by David Bacon

Last month, 600 workers at the Chipotle fast food chain were fired in Minnesota.

Their crime? Working.

In the last two years, thousands of others have been fired for the same offense — 2000 young women working at Los Angeles sewing machines, 500 apple pickers in eastern Washington, hundreds of janitors in Minnesota and California, and many, many more. They’re all victims of the administration’s “softer” immigration enforcement strategy.

Its logic is brutal: Make it impossible for 12 million undocumented people in the United States to earn a living, or buy food, pay rent, or send money home to their children. Then they’ll deport themselves. When their families hear they can’t get jobs in the United States, they won’t join those already here.

This same inhuman logic convinced Congress to pass the Immigration Reform and Control Act in 1986. For 25 years, employers have had to verify workers’ immigration status, and cannot legally employ people without papers. The real impact, though, is on workers. It’s become a crime to hold a job.

The justification has always been the same. Undocumented immigrants will go home if they can’t work. But no one has. During those 25 years, NAFTA and CAFTA and pro-corporate market reforms in Mexico and other developing countries, profoundly deepened the poverty driving people from their homes. More people came than ever before.

Among them were those 600 mostly Mexican workers, who got minimum-wage jobs serving Mexican food at Chipotle. Many of them worked years for the company. Then the Department of Homeland Security audited Chipotle’s personnel records, found incorrect Social Security numbers, and in December sent the company a list of workers it had to fire.

Alejandro Juarez, who worked at the Calhoun Lake restaurant in Minneapolis, says his manager told him not to bother coming back the next day. He’d spent five years cleaning and fixing the stoves, grills and refrigerators, for $9.42 an hour. “The company used us,” he says, “and when it didn’t serve them anymore, they threw us away like trash.”

John Morton, head of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) says that ICE plans many more mass firings. The ICE website says it targets employers “who are using illegal workers to drive down wages … [those] likely to pay illegal workers substandard wages or force them to endure intolerable working conditions.”

At Chipotle, however, as in every other sanctions target, ICE never improved conditions. Wages remain the same. In fact, although Morton boasts ICE collected $7 million in employer fines during 2,740 audits, those who cooperated in firing workers were given immunity. The only people penalized were workers.

Fortunately, in Minneapolis, workers first found the Center for Workers United in Struggle, a local workers’ center. With its help, they made an alliance with the city’s janitors’ union, Service Employees Local 26. The local union had already been hit by audits that led to the firing of hundreds of its members, including stewards, officers and core activists.

Janitors had marched in the streets, while the union tried to help them survive. Together, Chipotle workers and building cleaners picketed the restaurants, where several supporters were arrested in protest.

As these firings spread, many other unions will face the same situation. Some, like the janitors’ locals in Minneapolis and San Francisco, have looked for ways to fight. Their first concern has been survival, and they’ve sought time extensions, back wages and vacation already owed, and severance. In Minneapolis, the workers also demand that Chipotle support immigration reform. That puts the human rights of immigrants squarely in the center of the table.

Congress’ comprehensive immigration reform proposals of the last five years would not have stopped these firings — in fact, most bills would have increased them. But though Congress is moving rightwards, many immigrant rights groups and unions are moving left.

They demand reforms that would reinforce the human and labor rights of people like the janitors and Chipotle workers. One proposal, the Dignity Campaign, calls for legal status for the undocumented, for repealing employer sanctions, and for ending trade policies that lead to forced migration.

That reflects the position unions adopted at the AFL-CIO convention in 1999. They argued then that immigrant workers had to be able to organize in order to improve Chipotle-level wages and conditions. Making work a crime made organizing harder, while pitting workers against each other during times of high unemployment.

San Francisco’s hotel union later won a decision invalidating firings for bad Social Security numbers. Unions even got a court injunction against Bush’s regulation mandating such terminations.

After 1999, however, some unions supported the CIR bills because they promised limited legalization, even at the price of more workplace enforcement. And most recently, the AFL-CIO’s Building and Construction Trades Department called for stepped-up sanctions enforcement without legalization.

Unions will have to choose whether to defend workers or not. There is no doubt that thousands more will be fired, even in an economy with double-digit unemployment. And these firings are indispensable to an enforcement regime that last year produced 395,000 deportations, and 345,000 people in detention. Rumors in Washington now whisper that if there’s too much protest, ICE will go back to the Bush-style raids.

But the janitors and Chipotle workers have shown the country a crucial fact. Even without papers, they’ve been willing to stand up. “We have to make our rights count for something,” Juarez says. “We’re not criminals. We have to say what we think, and let the company and government see we’re united.”

Now it’s up to unions and immigrant rights organizations to stand up with them, to demand, not just that the firings and deportations stop, but that a real immigration reform guarantee basic human and labor rights.


For more articles and photographs on immigrants and labor issues, see David Bacon, Photographs and Stories:

Art by Christa Occhiogrosso

Art by Christa Occhiogrosso

Resurrection of the Poor People’s Campaign

Rev. Barber told the activists gathered in the nation’s capital that by demonstrating in solidarity with poor people, they had become a link in the long history of people who fought for justice.

Hate Crime Laws Needed to Protect the Homeless

As homelessness becomes more visible, people living on the streets are targeted for bullying, assaults, harassment and even murders.

Life Is A Precious Gift: Mother Teresa’s House in Washington

We will never know how many huge pots of soup Jacob lifted with the sisters into trucks, to take to the homeless in the park. We will never know how many diseased bodies he fed, held and bathed, and the number of tears he dried in the early morning hours.

Mother Teresa’s Gift of Love in San Francisco

She took home with her the men who had only a few days left to live and were suffering the most, and tenderly cared for them around the clock. I am certain some of the people I was meeting were angels, whose job was to make certain no soul died alone and unloved.

My Back Pages: A Song for Miss Kay

She softly sings the soul anthem “Stand By Me.” It is a song for Miss Kay, a song for all of us. Her life, with its music and joy, followed by a downward slide into homelessness and death, tells us something deeper than words about the human condition.

My Back Pages: Kerry’s Kids, An Undying Dream

Oakland pediatrician Dr. Karen Kruger said, “Kerry’s death was so sudden and seemingly purposeless and shocking that I think there was a need for people that loved her to carry on her memory in a way that she would look down on from her cloud and be happy about.”