A Quaker’s Ceaseless Quest for a World Without War

After a lifetime of civil rights sit-ins, blockades at nuclear plants, and acts of anti-war resistance, David Hartsough remains a utopian believer in peace and justice. His latest campaign is perhaps the most quixotic of all. It dreams the impossible dream of a world that has abolished war.

David Hartsough is arrested by police in San Francisco for blocking Market Street in an act of civil disobedience in resistance to the U.S. invasion of Iraq.

 

by Terry Messman

During a long lifetime spent working for peace and social justice, David Hartsough has shown an uncanny instinct for being in the right place at the right time. One can almost trace the modern history of nonviolent movements in America by following the trail of his acts of resistance over the past 60 years.

His life has been an unbroken series of sit-ins for civil rights, seagoing blockades of munitions ships sailing for Vietnam, land blockades of trains carrying bombs to El Salvador, arrests at the Diablo nuclear reactor and the Livermore nuclear weapons lab, Occupy movement marches, and international acts of peacemaking in Russia, Nicaragua, Kosovo, Iran and Palestine.

It all began at the very dawn of the Freedom Movement when the teenaged Hartsough met Martin Luther King and Ralph David Abernathy at a church in Montgomery, Alabama, in 1956 as the ministers were organizing the bus boycott at the birth of the civil rights struggle.

Next, while at Howard University, Hartsough was involved in some of the first sit-ins to integrate restaurants in Arlington, Virginia — white-hot confrontations that were violently attacked by white supremacists and the American Nazi Party.

Just as Hartsough was present at Dr. King’s first campaign in Alabama, he also was arrested for taking part in the slain civil rights leader’s very last campaign, the Poor People’s Campaign in 1968.

During the Vietnam War, Hartsough helped organize a seagoing Peace Blockade that gained international attention after activists in small boats sailed directly into the path of the USS Nitro. When seven sailors jumped overboard to join the peace flotilla’s resistance to the Vietnam War, it made headlines across the country.

He was standing right next to his friend Brian Willson during a blockade of weapons shipments to Central America, when a munitions train ran over Willson, severing his legs and fracturing his skull.

Two months later, in November 1987, Concord police broke Hartsough’s arm while violently removing him from those same tracks where he was blocking a train.

Hartsough also was arrested in one of the most momentous anti-nuclear actions in our nation’s history, the blockade of the Diablo Canyon nuclear reactor. When the anti-nuclear power movement evolved into a movement against nuclear weapons, he was arrested repeatedly at Livermore Lab.

During a massive uprising in Kosovo,  he was arrested for conducting nonviolent trainings, and the jailing of U.S. activists created an international uproar.

In all these campaigns and many more, he seemed to be guided as if by the hands of destiny to be present at some of the most epochal movements for social change.

Quakers in the Oval Office

Perhaps the most striking case of serendipity occurred when Hartsough, at the age of 22, ended up in the Oval Office with a Quaker delegation that urged President John F. Kennedy to take immediate actions for disarmament and world peace. Hartsough also took the same message of peace to the Kremlin as the United States and Soviet Union stood on the very brink of nuclear war.

Quakers have a long and remarkable history of speaking truth to power. In his recent book JFK and the Unspeakable, peace activist and theologian James Douglass described the significant impact that John F. Kennedy’s meeting with six Quakers in the Oval Office on May 1, 1962, had on the president. Douglass wrote: “Kennedy’s dialogue with the Quakers was a hopeful sign of what would come in the last year of his presidency, when he would make a crucial turn toward peace.” [JFK and the Unspeakable, p. 325.]

Hartsough called himself “the token young guy” on a six-person Quaker delegation that met with President Kennedy to discuss world peace and nuclear disarmament at a time when the threat of nuclear war had reached an historic high point.

The others invited to the Oval Office made up a who’s who of prominent Quaker peace advocates: Ed Snyder and Samuel Levering, executive secretary and chairperson, respectively, of the Friends Committee on National Legislation; Henry Cadbury, a professor at Harvard Divinity School and the chairperson of the American Friends Service Committee; Dorothy Hutchinson, president of the U.S. section of the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom; and George Willoughby, who had sailed on the Golden Rule into the nuclear testing area in the Pacific.

In an interview with Street Spirit, Hartsough described his meeting with JFK. “Kennedy met with us in his office, sitting in his rocking chair next to the fireplace, and we sat around him, and he listened to us. We told him there was a nuclear submarine that was to be named the William Penn, and that was totally unacceptable.”

Penn, the founder of Pennsylvania, was a Quaker and a pacifist. Naming a nuclear submarine the William Penn is exactly the same as naming a battleship the USS Gandhi or a jet bomber the St. Francis of Assisi.

Hartsough said, “Kennedy just grinned and told us, ‘I’ll see that it doesn’t happen.’ ” The president was as good as his word, and the nuclear-armed submarine was not named after the Quaker pacifist.

Then, the delegation proceeded to make even more utopian requests on the president. “At that time, in China, there was a drought and many people were dying,” Hartsough explained. “China was, of course, our arch-enemy then, in addition to Russia. And the United States was spending millions of dollars to store food in grain siloes. So we suggested giving food to China.”

Kennedy said, “You mean feeding the enemy?’

The delegation said, “Yes, that’s exactly what we mean.” The Quaker team reminded the Catholic JFK that unconditional love and feeding the poor went to the heart of the New Testament.

Then, they addressed the terribly urgent concern that had brought them to meet with the president as the world faced the very real possibility of nuclear war. They asked Kennedy to stop nuclear testing and to move the nation away from the growing threat of nuclear disaster.

Challenging JFK to a ‘Peace Race’

“I encouraged Kennedy to challenge the Russians to a peace race,” Hartsough said. “Instead of having an arms race where one side builds an atomic bomb, so the other side gets an atomic bomb, and then the first side gets a hydrogen bomb. So why not try to go in the other direction, towards disarmament.”

Kennedy’s thoughtful response placed some of the responsibility back on the shoulders of peace activists. He said the idea of a peace race was a very interesting concept. But he added, “If you guys are serious about us moving in that direction, the military is very strong, so you are going to have to build a powerful movement to help me make that decision.”

The president’s secretary came in after 25 minutes and said, “Mr. President, your next appointment is here.” Kennedy said, “Tell them to wait, I’m learning something from these Quakers.”

All six members of the Quaker delegation were highly impressed by Kennedy’s listening with an open mind to the radical antiwar values of the delegation, and his evident sincerity in understanding the urgent need to work for world peace.

“I think most important to me was, first, that he listened,” Hartsough said. “He wasn’t just pontificating as if he was the president and we were lowly peons. And, second, we were speaking truth to power in the White House, and Kennedy wasn’t just rejecting it as hogwash.”

Kennedy only had 18 more months to live from the time of this meeting to his assassination in November 1963. In that short time, he stopped atmospheric nuclear weapons testing, de-escalated the Cuban missile crisis instead of pushing the button to unleash nuclear weapons on the Soviet Union, took important steps to stop the escalation of a nuclear confrontation in Berlin, and made the decision to bring U.S. advisers out of Vietnam.

Hartsough said that Kennedy had run for president as a Cold Warrior, and his growing awareness of the need for peace and disarmament was a hopeful sign.

Hartsough said, “As Jim Douglass, I think, would agree, our meeting may have helped plant some seeds about taking steps for peace later in his presidency. But I think it was the Cuban missile crisis that really scared the daylights out of him and Khrushchev, and helped Kennedy decide to take the courageous steps for peace he did in the latter part of his presidency.”

True to his Quaker beliefs in speaking truth to power, the young David Hartsough spoke out for disarmament on both sides of the Cold War. While a student at Howard University, he studied for a year abroad in East and West Berlin.

“At that time,” he said, “the United States and the Soviet Union were threatening to blow each other off the map and kill hundreds of millions of people in a nuclear war because we had so dehumanized ‘the other.’ They were no longer human beings. They were enemies.

“We had psyched ourselves up in our anti-communist crusade. And the Soviet Union had taken a similar stand against the capitalist, imperialist, American warmongers. So Berlin was the one place in the world where I could study both in the Communist world and the Western world, and get a deeper understanding into what both sides were saying.”

Again, a fateful sense of timing landed him in Berlin in 1961, the year that the Berlin Wall was built, a time of rising tension and perilous confrontation between the United States and the Soviet Union.

 Camping — and protesting — in Russia

Hartsough had learned that was it permissible to go camping in the Soviet Union, and it only cost two dollars per day for the visa and the permission to camp. As Hartsough and four other students started off on the road between Berlin and Moscow, he said, “all of a sudden tanks and trucks full of soldiers were headed toward Berlin to help build the Berlin Wall.”

He had studied Russia in college and seized the opportunity to “get to know the Russian people — these people we were threatening to bomb off the face of the earth.”

His group spent about a month on a 6,000-mile trip through Russia and the Ukraine. They camped out and were invited into people’s homes for meals. One of their guides spoke fluent Russian, so they had in-depth conversations with people in their homes, churches and farming villages.

Hartsough took two more groups of 18 students into Russia in the next two years. He wrote an AFSC booklet about the trip called Backyard Russia: Getting to Know the Russian People. He said, “When you get to know the people as human beings, it’s even more difficult to think about bombing their homes and their families.”

Yet he was dismayed to find that the Russian people’s view of the United States was distorted with the same Cold War propaganda he had heard at home.

“ They had the same kind of mentality that Americans had. They had been fed propaganda also, and saw their nuclear bombs as peaceful bombs.”

Some questions that the Russian people asked about the United States really struck home.

“We were in Russia during the Freedom Rides when buses were burning up and people were being beaten for riding them,” Hartsough said. “So they really challenged us, saying, ‘You call yourselves a democracy, but why is your country doing this stuff?’”

The Quixotic Quaker vs. the Pentagon and Kremlin

A month after his meeting with Kennedy, Hartsough was arrested for holding a prayer vigil in front of the White House calling for an end to nuclear weapons testing. His sign said, “Bomb Tests Kill People,” and he was jailed in Washington, D.C.

Later that summer, he was in Russia, and realized nobody was going to challenge the Russian bomb tests. So Hartsough and a fellow student carried the exact same message to Red Square, holding a sign saying, in Russian, “Bomb Tests Kill People.”

They stood in a silent vigil holding the sign right next to the Kremlin and the Lenin mausoleum. People would come up and say, “Why are you against our peaceful bombs?” And, “Go back to the United States and demonstrate there.”

Hartsough replied, “We did demonstrate in the United States, and they told us to go demonstrate in Russia!”

Then the Soviet police came and told them it was illegal to demonstrate against their “peaceful bombs” and they could get 20 years in prison.

“We told the police we had been arrested a month ago in front of the White House for offering the same message,” Hartsough said.

The police left, saying they had to talk with their superiors about what to do. They were not arrested, but Russian officials decided not to let Hartsough back in Russia for 26 years. “For 26 years, I was persona non grata — until Gorbachev,” he said.

David Hartsough demonstrates in Moscow’s Red Square against Soviet nuclear weapons testing. Soviet police threatened him with 20 years in prison for the protest. Hartsough had just been arrested at the White House for protesting U.S. nuclear tests.

 

The Quintessential Quaker

The first time I met David Hartsough was in February 1982, right after many of us were arrested at Livermore Laboratory in the first major act of civil disobedience at the nuclear weapons facility. A photo on the front page of that day’s Livermore newspaper showed Hartsough being dragged away by the police in handcuffs.

First impressions are interesting. The photo showed a man in a sports coat with short hair, glasses and a conservative appearance. Yet he had gone limp and refused to cooperate with the cop arresting him. Somehow, he looked like the quintessential Quaker, once again in handcuffs as Quaker dissenters so often were.

David’s father, Ray Hartsough, was a congregational minister who had refused to become a chaplain or be involved in the U.S. military. Ray Hartsough went to Gaza with the AFSC and the United Nations in 1949, and spent nine months going through the battle lines and bringing food, medicine and tents to refugees.

This made a deep impression on 8-year-old David. “He was willing to put his own life on the line for people he had never met,” he said of his father.

Hartsough’s father became a Quaker and began working with the AFSC, and David got to know the “amazing people” his father brought to their home — civil rights activists Ralph David Abernathy and Bayard Rustin, and Quaker activists Steve Cary and Clarence Pickett.

David also became a Quaker at age 13, and he has been a Quaker his entire adult life. His wife, Jan Hartsough, a dedicated activist on food and hunger issues, is also a Quaker. Both David and Jan are peace and justice activists who worked with the AFSC for nearly two decades.

A Denomination as Tiny as Leaven

Quakers are a very tiny denomination in the United States — as tiny as leaven. Yet they have had a major impact on peace and justice movements, out of all proportion to their numbers. Quakers have been an integral part of the movement to abolish slavery, the Underground Railroad, the suffrage movement to win the right to vote for women, the civil rights movement, the anti-war movement, the Sanctuary movement, the anti-nuclear movement, and the prison reform movement.

Quakers have been such a central part of so many campaigns for peace and justice, it is hard to believe that there are only an estimated 87,000 Quakers in the United States. By comparison, there are 75 million Catholics, 13.5 million Lutherans and 8 million Methodists in the U.S.

I asked what being a lifelong Quaker has meant to him. He explained that Quakers try to speak out for justice and peace in the world, both as individuals and through the organizations they have created, including the Friends Committee for National Legislation (FCNL), the American Friends Service Committee (AFSC) and their denominational body, the Religious Society of Friends.

“Quakers believe that all people are created by God,” he said. “We’re all children of God, so we are brothers and sisters. So we have a responsibility to one another if someone is hungry or in prison or in a war zone. Quakers try to live by their values and beliefs: love and compassion and caring for one another, and for the planet and the environment.”

It is a central article of faith to seek justice for homeless and hungry people, and for prisoners and refugees. And it is crucial to alleviate the suffering caused by warfare. “The causes of war are nationalism and greed and imperialism and we have a responsibility to address those causes of war,” Hartsough said.

Johnny Appleseed

The metaphor that best explains for me the life path of David Hartsough is Johnny Appleseed. Like Johnny Appleseed, he has planted many seeds, and catalyzed many movements and social justice campaigns, and then he moves on over the next horizon to plant more seeds of peace.

His uncanny ability to be at the right place at the right time is a source of amazement to me. As the director of AFSC’s Nonviolent Movement Building Program for nearly two decades, David worked to help form the Pledge of Resistance and Nuremberg Action Group to oppose U.S. military intervention in Central America. He did the nonviolence trainings to prepare Witness for Peace teams on peacemaking missions to Nicaragua, and then spent several months in Nicaragua with their volunteers.

He helped form the Peace Navy that joined longshoremen in blocking the unloading of South African cargo ships in the anti-apartheid movement. He conducted nonviolence trainings for the Abalone Alliance, and he worked with Native Americans in the Four Corners area of the Southwest and at DQ University when it was threatened with closure.

Another apple seed that Hartsough planted was the creation of AFSC’s Homeless Organizing Project, a program that organized many years of housing takeovers and civil disobedience in protest of society’s mistreatment of homeless people, and then began publishing Street Spirit in 1995.

The Nonviolent Movement Building Program launched the homeless program, Hartsough explained, to “challenge our society’s inhumanity and neglect of homeless people, challenging the governments that criminalized homeless people.”

While attending seminary at the Graduate Theological Union in Berkeley, I did my field ministry with Hartsough’s Nonviolent Movement Building Program, rather than at a church, even though I am not a Quaker.

My past 30 years of work on homeless issues — along with all of the housing takovers and arrests and the entire 20-year history of Street Spirit — is only one of the innumerable projects that Hartsough has catalyzed, just one of the many apple seeds he has planted along the way.

Still Utopian After All These Years

Hartsough was only 14 when he organized his first nonviolent protest at a Nike missile plant. Now, 60 years later, he remains as actively involved as ever. Many people begin their lives as idealists or radicals, but as the years pass by, they become more moderate, more “reasonable,” often even more conservative.

By contrast, David Hartsough remains, more than ever, the utopian believer in global peace and economic justice for all. His latest campaign is called A World Beyond War, and it is perhaps the most quixotic and utopian campaign of all. It dreams the impossible dream of a world that has abolished war.

“Imagine all the people living life in peace,” as John Lennon sang.

World Beyond War is just such a daring attempt to imagine a world at peace, and then organize for the creation of such a world. More than 4,000 people have signed its Declaration of Peace, pledging to work nonviolently to end all wars.

“You may say I’m a dreamer, but I’m not the only one,” Lennon reminded us.

Hartsough recently returned from a trip to Southeast Asia in April. He met with peace activists in South Korea and joined priests and nuns on Jeju Island protesting the construction of a massive military base at the port of Gangjeong by nonviolently blocking bulldozers and cement trucks. [See “A Journey of Peace in Korea and Vietnam” in this issue of Street Spirit.]

Coming Home to Vietnam

He then spent two weeks in Vietnam as part of a Veterans for Peace delegation hosted by a group of American Vietnam veterans living in Vietnam.

Hartsough had been arrested many times during the war for acts of resistance to the massacres, bombings and battlefield atrocities. He also was a full-time lobbyist hired by the Friends Committee on National Legislation to try to stop the Vietnam War in the 1960s. His work was to lobby Congress and interact with peace groups around the country. Hartsough and other Quakers had been arrested week after week for reading the names of the war dead to the U.S. Congress.

When I asked what it felt like to finally travel to Vietnam for the first time after spending so many years of his life organizing to end the war, he called it a profoundly emotional homecoming. “In a way, it was just like coming home,” he said. Yet, he was coming home to a place he had never even visited before this year.

He explained, “I had put in so many hours every day when I was a Quaker lobbyist trying to help members of Congress and the American people understand the reality of what that war was doing to the people of Vietnam. I was arrested and jailed a number of times for trying to prevent the bombs and weapons from being sent to Vietnam, and to stop the horrendous war the United States was inflicting on them. But I had never been there.

“So it was like coming home to get to know the Vietnamese people. Here is my family that I really cared deeply about, but I had never met them. And the friendliness and the openness of the Vietnamese people was so deeply moving to me.”

It was hard to fathom the friendliness and humanity he found in a land ravaged by U.S. bombs and where the toxic after-effects of Agent Orange have created an epidemic of human suffering.

“It was my country that had dropped millions of tons of bombs and Agent Orange, and the unexploded ordnance from that war is still killing their children now,” he said. “Yet, their humanity to us, as Americans, was just mind-boggling. If some other country had bombed the United States to smithereens, and 30 years later they came to the U.S., I can’t imagine we’d be inviting them into our homes, and be so friendly and open with them.”

It is a small miracle, this friendliness from the citizens of a country that the U.S. targeted with saturation bombing, napalm and anti-personnel weapons.

The word “Friend” is synonymous with the word “Quaker.” It seems fitting that a Friend from North America would find friends in Vietnam — a country that he had always steadfastly refused to believe was an enemy.

Street Spirit Interview with David Hartsoogh: Part 1

* * * * * * *

Waging Peace: Global Adventures of a Lifelong Activist

by David Hartsough

Published by PM Press, November 2014, 272 pages

Available on Amazon.com

* * * * * * *

Book Readings by David Hartsough

Sunday, November 2, 1 p.m

San Francisco Friends Center, 65 Ninth Street, San Francisco

Sunday, November 9, 7 p.m.

Berkeley Unitarian Universalist Fellowship, 1924 Cedar (at Bonita), Berkeley

Come meet author and activist David Hartsough. David will read from his new book Waging Peace: Global Adventures of a Lifelong Activist, and discuss his adventures in peacemaking.

Tags:

West Oakland Loses Alliance Metals after Nearly 40 Years

Despite our campaign and collective offer to raise the funds, services and volunteers to balance neighborhood complaints and concerns with the basic needs of recyclers to earn a livelihood, Alliance Metals is now closed.

Oakland’s Inhumane “Abatement” of Homeless People

Oakland dehumanizes people by referring to “debris abatement and homeless abatement.” Abatement refers to trash or noise, not people. They are human beings, not debris, and must not be eliminated, or scrubbed away.

S.F. Homeless Project Served Only the Status Quo

A community slowly robbed of spaces to live, places to worship or recreate, let alone places to sleep, has a deep poverty of leadership. The few reporters who notice need to write about that deficit: the real story.

Oakland Robs the Poor of Dignity and Their Daily Bread

Destroying Alliance Recycling is not about compassion, Mayor Schaaf. It is hateful and harmful prejudice masquerading as law. By any definition, the systematic discrimination, incrimination and elimination of a vulnerable population of poor and homeless people is a form of state-sanctioned violence.

Advocacy Journalism and the Movement for Human Rights

What matters in the long run is staying true to the cause of justice. In the end, that is the very meaning of our lives — whether we keep going, and keep working for peace and justice, or give up in despair. It’s the question at the very heart of it all.

Street Newspapers and the Legacy of Justice Journalism

Radical and dissenting journalists were part of nearly every social-change movement and populist rebellion in U.S. history. In their day, they were hated by the powerful, and condemned as muckrakers, agitators and disturbers of the piece. Many are now remembered as exemplary models of journalism with a social conscience.